← All insightsTimetable design

Should the timetable be built around moving sets?

Every set move starts in the timetable.

When I was building timetables, one of my main priorities was keeping sets flexible. Maths blocked in parallel. English blocked in parallel. Science lined up so any student could move up or down at any point in the year.

What that flexibility costs

Blocking a subject in parallel means every class in that year group has the subject at the same time. It makes moving a student between sets easy, because they simply go to a different room in the same lesson.

But it isn’t free. To block a whole year group’s Maths at once, you need enough Maths teachers free at the same time, and enough suitable rooms. Every block you fix like that leaves fewer choices for everything else.

It cost a lot. Fewer options in other blocks. Tighter staffing. Compromises somewhere else. I assumed it was worth it.

What the research found

New research from the National Institute of Teaching looked at more than 10,000 students across 21 secondary schools. It found that moving students between sets during the year generally didn’t improve their attainment.

Moving up didn’t lead to better results in English, Maths, History or Geography. Science was the only exception. Moving down was usually followed by lower attainment. The researchers suggest the disruption of changing classes rarely pays for itself.

What it doesn’t tell us

It’s one trust and one year, and it doesn’t prove cause and effect. Students who are moved down may already be struggling for other reasons, and one trust’s approach to setting won’t match every school’s.

But it made me rethink the question timetablers should be asking. Not “Can we move them?” but “Should the timetable be built around moving them at all?”

Three things I’d now consider

Get September right

Put more effort into the first setting decision, using good data and talking to the previous teacher, so you don’t rely on fixing it later. If the starting point is right, fewer moves are needed.

Make movement a planned decision, not a constant

Agree one or two review points a year. That beats a steady stream of “can we just swap them?” requests. Students, parents and teachers know when changes can happen, and the timetable only needs to make moves easy at those points.

Question the cost of parallel blocking

If flexibility rarely changes outcomes, what could that freedom in the schedule be used for instead? For example, better option combinations, more balanced teaching loads, or specialist rooms used more evenly across the week. It’s worth looking at what you gave up to keep sets flexible, and whether it was worth it.

Questions to ask before next year’s timetable

  • How many students actually moved sets last year, and when?
  • Which subjects are blocked in parallel, and why?
  • What would the timetable look like if one of those blocks was freed up?
  • Who decides when a student moves, and on what evidence?

Every set move looks small on paper. To a student, it means a new teacher, new classmates and starting again. The timetable decides how easy it is to make that move. It should probably also decide how rare it is.

If you’d like an independent look at how your curriculum and blocking are set up, that’s what a curriculum and timetable review is for. Read more about curriculum and timetable reviews.

How often does your school move students between sets during the year?

Source: the National Institute of Teaching’s TIDE research project.

Thinking about how your blocking is set up for next year?

Book a call

Start here

Let’s talk about your timetable

A 30-minute call, no charge. Tell me where you are and I’ll tell you honestly whether I can help.